ITPCAS和CMORPH两种遥感降水产品在陕西地区的适用性

doi:10.13866/j.azr.2018.03.10

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 与气象站观测数据相比,遥感降水产品能够更好地反映降水的空间分布特征。利用36个国家标准气象站点以及23个区域气象站点的观测数据,通过对降水事件的探测能力、不同降水量级的捕捉率和不同时空尺度的降水量误差等指标的分析,评估ITPCAS和CMORPH两种高时空分辨率的遥感降水产品在陕西地区的适用性。结果表明:ITPCAS在多年平均日降水误差、空报率、漏报率、中雨及以上降水等级的捕捉率、多年平均年降水的空间分布及站点误差等方面,均显著好于CMORPH,能够较好地体现陕西地区降水的空间分布特征和变化趋势。

关键词: CMORPH, ITPCAS, 遥感, 降水产品, 适用性, 陕西

Abstract: Compared with the precipitation data from meteorological stations,the precipitation products based on remote sensing can be used to well present the spatial distribution of precipitation,whereas the accuracy of remote sensing products generally cannot match that of the meteorological stations.Thus it is necessary to evaluate the common used precipitation products.In this paper,the reliability of two satellites precipitation products ITPCAS and CMORPH with high spatial-temporal resolution over Shaanxi Province was evaluated using the observed data from 36 national and 23 regional meteorological stations.Analysis based on the indexes including the detection rate of precipitation events,capture rate over all precipitation magnitudes and errors of precipitation at different spatial-temporal scales were adopted in the evaluation.Results showed that the ITPCAS was accurate for the Shaanxi region because of its low bias of average daily precipitation,low false alarming ratio and missed ratio,high capture rate of precipitation for grades higher than moderate magnitude,good presentation of the distribution and variation pattern of the precipitation.The spatial distribution and change pattern of precipitation in the Shaanxi region could be well presented by ITPCAS precipitation.CMORPH also showed the spatial distribution pattern of precipitation in the Shaanxi region.However,the errors were comparatively higher as CMORPH did not merge any data from meteorological stations.Further revisions of the CMORPH are needed to ensure the accuracy of the products.

Key words: CMORPH, ITPCAS, remote sensing, precipitation product, applicability, Shaanxi Province

王玉丹, 陈浩, 刘璨然, 丁永建. ITPCAS和CMORPH两种遥感降水产品在陕西地区的适用性[J]. 干旱区研究, 2018, 35(3): 579-588.

WANG Yu-dan, CHEN Hao, LIU Can-ran, DING Yong-jian. Applicability of ITPCAS and CMORPH Precipitation Datasets over Shaanxi Province[J]. Arid Zone Research, 2018, 35(3): 579-588.

参考文献

〔1〕徐小钰,朱记伟,解建仓,等.陕西省1470—2012年旱涝灾害时空分布特征及演变趋势分析〔J〕.西安理工大学学报,2015,31(2):231-237.〔Xu Xiaoyu,Zhu Jiwei,Xie Jiancang,et al.Analysis of spatial and temporal distribution characteristics and evolution trend of drought and flood disasters from 1470 to 2012 in Shaanxi Province〔J〕.Journal of Xi’an University of Technology,2015,31(2):231-237.〕
〔2〕任国玉,袁玉江,柳艳菊,等.我国西北干燥区降水变化规律〔J〕.干旱区研究,2016,33(1):1-19.〔Ren Guoyu,Yuan Yujiang,Liu Yanju,et al.Changes in precipitation over Northwest China〔J〕.Arid Zone Research,2016,33(1):1-19.〕
〔3〕王炳钦,江源,董满宇,等.1961—2010年北方半干旱区极端降水时空变化〔J〕.干旱区研究,2016,33(5):913-920.〔Wang Bingqin,Jiang Yuan,Dong Manyu,et al.Spatiotemporal variations of extreme precipitation in the semiarid region in north China during the period of 1961-2010〔J〕.Arid Zone Research,2016,33(5):913-920.〕
〔4〕李英杰,延军平,刘永林.秦岭南北气候干湿变化与降水非均匀性的关系〔J〕.干旱区研究,2016,33(3):619-627.〔Li Yingjie,Yan Junping,Liu Yonglin.Relationship between dryness/wetness and precipitation heterogeneity in the north and south of the Qinling Mountain 〔J〕.Arid Zone Research,2016,33(3):619-627.〕
〔5〕季漩,罗毅.TRMM降水数据在中天山区域的精度评估分析〔J〕.干旱区地理,2013,36(2):253-262.〔Ji Xuan,Luo Yi.Quality assessment of the TRMM precipitation data in mid Tianshan mountains 〔J〕.Arid Land Geography,2013,36(2):253-262.〕
〔6〕 Chen Y,Yang K,He J,et al.Improving land surface temperature modeling for dry land of China〔J〕.Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres,2011,116(D20104):12-20.
〔7〕 Joyce R J,Janowiak J E,Arkin P A,et al.CMORPH:A method that produces global precipitation estimates from passive microwave and infrared data at high spatial and temporal resolution〔J〕.Journal of Hydrometeorology,2004,5(3):487-503.
〔8〕 Huffman G J,Bolvin D T,Nelkin E J,et al.The TRMM Multisatellite Precipitation Analysis(TMPA):Quasi-global,Multiyear,Combined-sensor Precipitation Estimates at Fine Scales〔M〕.Netherlands:Springer,2010:3-22.
〔9〕王芬,曹杰,李腹广,等.多套格点降水资料在云南及周边地区的对比〔J〕.应用气象学报,2013,24(4):472-483.〔Wang Fen,Cao Jie,Li Fuguang,et al.Datasets and rain gauge precipitation over Yunnan and the surrounding areas〔J〕.Journal of Applied Meteorological Science,2013,24(4):472-483.〕
〔10〕江志红,卢尧,丁裕国.基于时空结构指标的中国融合降水资料质量评估〔J〕.气象学报,2013,71(5):891-900.〔Jiang Zhihong,Lu Yao,Ding Yuguo.Analysis of the high-resolution merged precipitation products over China based on the temporal and spatial structure score indices〔J〕.Acta Meteorologica Sinica,2013,71(5):891-900.〕
〔11〕胡增运,倪勇勇,邵华,等.CFSR、ERA-Interim和MERRA降水资料在中亚地区的适用性〔J〕.干旱区地理,2013,36(4):700-708.〔Hu Zengyun,Ni Yongyong,Shao Hua,et al.Applicability study of CFSR,ERA-Interim and MERRA precipitation estimates in Central Asia〔J〕.Arid Land Geography,2013,36(4):700-708.〕
〔12〕姜贵祥,孙旭光.格点降水资料在中国东部夏季降水变率研究中的适用性〔J〕.气象科学,2016,36(4):448-456.〔Jiang Guixiang,Sun Xuguang.Reliabilities of gridded precipitation datasets in studying summer precipitation variabilities over the Eastern China〔J〕.Journal of the Meteorological Sciences,2016,36(4):448-456.〕
〔13〕阚宝云,苏凤阁,童凯,等.四套降水资料在喀喇昆仑山叶尔羌河上游流域的适用性分析〔J〕.冰川冻土,2013,35(3):710-722.〔Kan Baoyun,Su Fengge,Tong Kai,et al.Analysis of the applicability of four precipitation datasets in the upper reaches of the Yarkant River,the Karakorum〔J〕.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,2013,35(3):710-722.〕
〔14〕李琼,杨梅学,万国宁,等.TRMM 3B43降水数据在黄河源区的适用性评价〔J〕.冰川冻土,2016,38(3):620-633.〔Li Qiong,Yang Meixue,Wan Guoning,et al.Analysis of the accuracy of TRMM 3B43 precipitation data in the source region of the Yellow River〔J〕.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,2016,38(3):620-633.〕
〔15〕郝振纯,童凯,张磊磊,等.TRMM降水资料在青藏高原的适用性分析〔J〕.水文,2011,31(5):18-23.〔Hao Zhenchun,Tong Kai,Zhang Leilei,et al.Applicability analysis of TRMM precipitation estimates in Tibetan Plateau〔J〕.Journal of China Hydrology,2011,31(5):18-23.〕
〔16〕张蒙,黄安宁,计晓龙,等.卫星反演降水资料在青藏高原地区的适用性分析〔J〕.高原气象,2016,35(1):34-42.〔Zhang Meng,Huang Anning,Ji Xiaolong,et al.Validation of satellite precipitation products over Qinghai-Xizang Plateau region〔J〕.Plateau Meteorology,2016,35(1):34-42.〕
〔17〕许时光,牛铮,沈艳,等.CMORPH卫星降水数据在中国区域的误差特征研究〔J〕.遥感技术与应用,2014,29(2):189-194.〔Xu Shiguang,Niu Zheng,Shen Yan,et al.A research into the characteristics of CMORPH remote sensing precipitation error in China〔J〕.Remote Sensing Technology and Application,2014,29(2):189-194.〕
〔18〕沈艳,潘旸,宇婧婧,等.中国区域小时降水量融合产品的质量评估〔J〕.大气科学学报,2013,36(1):37-46.〔Shen Yan,Pan Yang,Yu Jingjing,et al.Quality assessment of hourly merged precipitation product over China〔J〕.Transactions of Atmospheric Sciences,2013,36(1):37-46.〕
〔19〕旷达,沈艳,牛铮,等.卫星反演降水产品误差随时空分辨率和雨强的变化特征分析〔J〕.遥感信息,2012,27(4):75-81.〔Kuang Da,Shen Yan,Niu Zheng,et al.analysis on uncertainty of satellite retrieved precipitation products〔J〕.Remote Sensing Information,2012,27(4):75-81.〕
〔20〕Shen Y,Xiong A,Wang Y,et al.Performance of High-Resolution Satellite Precipitation Products over China〔J〕.Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres,2010,115(D2):11-20.
〔21〕何思为,南卓铜,张凌,等.用VIC模型模拟黑河上游流域水分和能量通量的时空分布〔J〕.冰川冻土,2015,37(1):211-225.〔He Siwei,Nan Zhuotong,Zhang Ling,et al.Spatial-temporal distribution of water and energy fluxes in the upper reaches of the Heihe River simulated with VIC model〔J〕.Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology,2015,37(1):211-225.〕
〔22〕齐文文,张百平,庞宇,等.基于TRMM数据的青藏高原降水的空间和季节分布特征〔J〕.地理科学,2013,33(8):999-1 005.〔Qi Wenwen,Zhang Baiping,Pang Yu,et al.TRMM-data-based spatial and seasonal patterns of precipitation in the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau〔J〕.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2013,33(8):999-1 005.〕
〔23〕李慧,杨涛,何祺胜,等.新疆天山山区TRMM卫星降水数据的复合校正方法〔J〕.干旱区研究,2017,34(3):585-590.〔Li Hui,Yang Tao,He Qisheng,et al.Composite correction method of TRMM satellite precipitation data in the Tianshan Mountains,Xinjiang〔J〕.Arid Zone Research,2017,34(3):585-590.〕
〔24〕宇婧婧,沈艳,潘旸,等.概率密度匹配法对中国区域卫星降水资料的改进〔J〕.应用气象学报,2013,24(5):544-553.〔Yu Jingjing,Shen Yan,Pan Yang,et al.Improvement of satellite-based precipitation estimates over China based on probability density function matching method〔J〕.Journal of Applied Meteorological Science,2013,24(5):544-553.〕
〔25〕Liston G E,Elder K,A meteorological distribution system for high-resolution terrestrial modeling (MicroMet)〔J〕.Journal of Hydrometeorology,2006,7(2):217-234.
〔26〕Fieller E C,Hartley H O,Pearson E S.Tests for rank correltion coefficients〔J〕.Biometrika,1957,3(44):470-481.
〔27〕成璐,沈润平,师春香,等.CMORPH和TRMM 3B42降水估计产品的评估检验〔J〕.气象,2014,40(11):1 372-1 379.〔Cheng Lu,Shen Runping,Shi Chunxiang,et al.Evaluation and verification of CMORPH and TRMM 3B42 precipitation estimation products〔J〕.Meteorological Monthly,2014,40(11):1 372-1 379.〕
〔28〕Shen Y,Zhao P,Pan Y,et al.A high spatiotemporal gauge-satellite merged precipitation analysis over China〔J〕.Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres,2014,119(6):3 063-3 075.

[1]	李漠雨, 董少睿, 郭英香. 青藏高原东部三种降水数据产品的适用性评估[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(7): 1173-1183.
[2]	张雅静, 郝蕊芳. 中国北方农牧交错带东段不同类型流域水文模型适用性[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(6): 1021-1031.
[3]	魏倩, 马全林, 赵锐锋. 古浪县八步沙区域生态环境质量变化[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(6): 1114-1125.
[4]	方锋, 王静, 贾建英, 王兴, 黄鹏程, 殷菲, 林婧婧. 中国区域作物气象产量统计预报研究进展[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(4): 730-753.
[5]	强欣欢, 高文文, 王博, 谭剑波, 赵旦, 闫世勇, 隋立春. 基于遥感的土壤盐渍化风险评估及其演变规律[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(3): 431-444.
[6]	李琪, 党国锋, 鱼腾飞, 张浪, 陈薇宇. 基于GEE的干旱区县域生态环境质量时空变化及驱动力分析——以阿拉善左旗为例[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(2): 360-371.
[7]	于志翔, 杨霞, 于晓晶, 姜旭涛. 卫星降水产品对昆仑山北坡极端暴雨的监测能力及偏差分析[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(10): 1777-1790.
[8]	宋海清, 皇彦, 孙小龙. 五套土壤质地对IMLDAS表层土壤水分模拟的适用性[J]. 干旱区研究, 2025, 42(10): 1813-1827.
[9]	王怡雯, 马瑶瑶, 史培军, 张钢锋. 干旱区光伏电站运营对局地生态环境的影响[J]. 干旱区研究, 2024, 41(8): 1423-1433.
[10]	杨锁华, 李丽, 马江德, 郭文霞. “三生空间”视角下陕西省1990—2020年土地利用转型及梯度效应[J]. 干旱区研究, 2024, 41(7): 1249-1258.
[11]	马元植, 覃小林, 凌红波, 闫俊杰, 张广朋. 1991—2020年新疆中小湖泊面积变化时空特征及趋势分析[J]. 干旱区研究, 2024, 41(6): 905-916.
[12]	洪国军, 谢俊博, 张灵, 范振岐, 喻彩丽, 付仙兵, 李旭. 基于多光谱影像的阿拉尔垦区棉田土壤盐分反演[J]. 干旱区研究, 2024, 41(5): 894-904.
[13]	张华, 押海廷, 徐存刚. 兰州市南北两山土壤水分遥感反演及植被需水量估算[J]. 干旱区研究, 2024, 41(4): 566-580.
[14]	马瑶瑶, 史培军, 徐伟, 张钢锋. 干旱区水电站建设运营生态环境影响遥感监测[J]. 干旱区研究, 2023, 40(9): 1498-1508.
[15]	孟乘枫, 仲涛, 郑江华, 王南, 刘泽轩, 任祥源. 昆仑山冰湖分布时空特征及驱动力[J]. 干旱区研究, 2023, 40(7): 1094-1106.